Friday, May 7, 2010

Workflow 4 Bugfest - no compensations

According to msdn

"Compensation in Windows Workflow Foundation (WF) is the mechanism by which previously completed work can be undone or compensated (following the logic defined by the application) when a subsequent failure occurs. This section describes how to use compensation in workflows."

Ok. Lets start with this very simple example:


But when you execute it you will find that...

Pufffff, it's gone!

None of our handlers is ever called. Our transaction is down the drain.

Hmm, maybe the transaction was not successful and this is the reason why none of handlers got called.

Lets try this:

But when you execute it you will find that...

the last message is "Do Transaction" then

Pufffffs, it's gone.

But on the other hand what happens if we delete the throw?

Then we see that the confirmed handler gets called at the end of our workflow.

This means:

If we use CompensableActivity and everything in our workflow completes successfully, the transaction gets "autocommitted". Otherwise its puffff gone.

But this behavior can be changed from outside.

Lets wrap the first example into one of this mysterious Try/Catch Block and let him handle the exception.



What we now see that all of a sudden our CancellationHandler gets called.

I am confused now.

First thing is that I would never expect my Compensation to just puffff. I mean I do serious thing in a compensation. This makes especially no sense to me, if a successful Compensation auto-commits and the end of the workflow. An even less if failed compensation calls the cancellationhadler only if it is wrapped into a Try/Catch block that handles the exception.

Update: In the MSDN Forum Steve Danielson investigated the issue and gave an excellent hint on the difference between C# Try/Catch and Workflow Try/Catch. This covers the behavior for CompensableAction as well

No comments: